What happens when you combine a grilled cheese and a pimento cheese sandwich? Maybe one of the best lunches around! This grilled pimento cheese sandwich is savory, melty, crispy, and so perfect.

Two halves of a grilled pimento cheese sandwich arranged on a white plate with potato chips and a pickle spear.

I grew up eating loads and loads of pimento cheese sandwiches. 

They were pretty simple: my great-grandmother’s homemade pimento cheese on white bread, often with big slices of summer-fresh tomatoes. 

Don’t get me wrong, that’s pretty much a perfect sandwich, especially in the height of summer when tomatoes are at their very best. 

But it wasn’t until one of my friends shared about a grilled pimento cheese sandwich that she had on her honeymoon that it occurred to us to use pimento cheese in a grilled cheese sandwich.

LET ME TELL YOU, friends. I am sure glad my family saw the light on that one.

Get ready for one of the simplest yet most comforting sandwiches you could eat.

Side view of two halves of a grilled pimento cheese sandwich stacked on a white plate. A glass of iced tea is visible in the background.

MAKING A PERFECTLY CRISPY GRILLED CHEESE

Before we talk specifically about this grilled pimento cheese sandwich, let’s talk about my top tip for making an amazing grilled cheese sandwich:

Use mayonnaise on the outside of the bread instead of butter.

I grew up with my mom spreading butter on the outside of the sandwich before toasting our grilled cheese sandwiches and was an adult before I ever heard of using mayo for this purpose.

It sounds weird, I’ll admit. But don’t knock it until you try it: it WORKS!

One reason I prefer to use mayo is because it spreads better on soft breads without tearing into the bread. 

The other reason I like using mayo is because it gives you a perfect crispy sandwich without any greasiness. And if you use a good mayo (we love using Duke’s or a homemade mayonnaise at our house), it’ll add extra flavor to the sandwich, too.

Oh, and one last tip for you:

Keep the heat to medium-low.

I know it’s tempting to crank up the heat on your griddle, but if you do, you risk burning the bread before the cheese is melted. Keep the heat lower so you get melty cheese and a golden crust.

Ingredients for a grilled pimento cheese sandwich on a marble countertop.

HOW TO MAKE A GRILLED PIMENTO CHEESE SANDWICH

If you work from home like I do, you’ll be tempted to whip up one of these sandwiches for lunch at least weekly. And really, no one could blame you!

Ingredients you’ll need

To make this grilled pimento cheese sandwich, you’ll need:

  • 2 slices of soft white or sourdough bread: I personally like a softer bread for this sandwich. You could use any bread you like, but I think a sandwich sourdough loaf is perfect.
  • ⅓ to ½ cup of my homemade pimento cheese: You could use any pimento cheese you like (as long as it’s not from a jar), but I’ll stick with my great-grandmother’s recipe.
  • 1 tablespoon of mayonnaise: Like I said above, I recommend using a good mayo so that you get some nice flavor added to your sandwich.

And that’s it! You can add slices of tomato if you like, but that’s totally optional.

Pimento cheese spread onto a slice of sourdough bread on a wooden cutting board.

Making grilled pimento cheese

Heat a griddle or skillet over medium-low heat while you prep your sandwich.

Spread the pimento cheese evenly over 1 slice of the bread and top with the second slice.

Spread the mayo evenly on the top and bottom of the sandwich, then place the sandwich on the heated skillet or griddle.

Cook for about 3 minutes per side, until the bread is golden brown on both sides and the cheese is melty.

Move the grilled pimento cheese sandwich to a cutting board and let it rest for 1-2 minutes before cutting and serving.

Assembled grilled pimento cheese sandwich on a wooden cutting board next to a butter knife and a small bowl of mayo.

SERVING SUGGESTIONS

I certainly don’t mind gobbling up this grilled pimento cheese sandwich alongside my favorite potato chips or a big bowl of fresh fruit.

But you could easily serve it up with a salad, such as my massaged kale salad, or with a bowl of soup, such as tortellini soup or corn chowder, if you’re looking for a bigger meal.

Oh, and don’t forget the pickles! My husband and daughter would say you have to have a pickle spear or some pickled cucumbers, too.

Bite taken from one half of a grilled pimento cheese sandwich on a white plate, next to a pickle and potato chips.
Grilled pimento cheese sandwich sliced in half on a white plate.

Grilled Pimento Cheese Sandwich

What happens when you combine a grilled cheese and a pimento cheese sandwich? Maybe one of the best lunches around! This grilled pimento cheese sandwich is savory, melty, crispy, and so perfect.
5 from 1 vote
Print Pin Rate
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Servings: 1

Ingredients 

Instructions

  • Heat a skillet or cast iron griddle over medium-low heat.
  • Spread the pimento cheese evenly over 1 slice of the bread. Top with the second slice.
  • Thinly spread the top and bottom of the sandwich with mayonnaise.
  • Place the sandwich on the heated skillet or griddle. Cook for about 3 minutes per side, until golden brown on both sides and the pimento cheese is melty.

Nutrition

Calories: 492kcal | Carbohydrates: 37g | Protein: 6g | Fat: 32g | Saturated Fat: 9g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 7g | Monounsaturated Fat: 3g | Trans Fat: 0.1g | Cholesterol: 49mg | Sodium: 1171mg | Potassium: 82mg | Fiber: 2g | Sugar: 10g | Vitamin A: 727IU | Vitamin C: 5mg | Calcium: 358mg | Iron: 2mg

24 Comments

  1. Yesss! Here’s a funny story. Daddy told me awhile ago that he never did like pimento cheese (before he had Ma-Ma’s), because all he knew about was said jarred stuff. Bless his heart. I’m glad that he’s seen the light on many culinary glories. And, it’s thanks to Christina and her Instagram post from her honeymoon that made me see the light. And that light is grilled pimento cheese. ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Heck, yeah! Why do you think that southern girls are what boys want (or the ones with any sense)? Did you catch her “opinionated southern grandmother” statement? Not that we don’t have a few of those in the family. ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Actually, pimento cheese isn’t remotely spicy! Pimentos aren’t spicy…more like finely chopped roasted red peppers. Kinda. But no spice! So you’d be fine ๐Ÿ™‚ (I’m a spice lightweight, too!)

    1. If I wasn’t busy this weekend I would be showing up at your doorstep with the ingredients for this sammich and force-feed it to you. The baby would approve.

    1. YES! Omg, I’m so glad someone else thinks that. I really wanted to write, “Make the danged sandwich. If you haven’t figured out how to do that by now, you’re doomed.” Haha.

    1. Well. You are a born and bred Yankee, so it isn’t really your fault that you weren’t raised right. ๐Ÿ˜‰ But really…this is such a Steph food. You neeeeed to try this.

  2. You make my heart swell…Let’s do this and a bowl of tomato soup for dipping…that’s it. I’ve got every meal planned from here on out. Grilled cheese and soup. done and done. I’ve never actually purchased a jar of pimentos. It is time, my friend…it is time. ๐Ÿ™‚

  3. Mmmm I love a good grilled cheese. I have never had pimento cheese, but I have seen that stuff in a jar. I thought that’s what it was! And that’s why I was really kind of confused at the end of the Food Network Star finale lol. Thanks for showing me the light. Looks amazing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating